I’ve been buying, selling, and gaming Scotty Cameron putters for over a decade. I’ve owned everything from a beat-up Studio Stainless I found for $175 to a Circle T that cost me more than my first car. The question “how much are Scotty Cameron putters?” never gets a simple answer because it depends on three things: what model you want, whether it’s new or used, and how rare it is.
Here’s the honest range: a new current-production Scotty Cameron will cost you $399 to $449. A used standard model runs $200 to $350. If you want a tour-level or limited edition, expect to pay $1,000 to $10,000 – and sometimes way more. I’ll break it all down so you know exactly what fits your budget and whether the deal you’re looking at is fair.
What Determines the Price of a Scotty Cameron Putter?
Every Scotty Cameron putter falls into one of three buckets, and the bucket decides the price.
Off-the-rack (OTR) models are the ones you see in golf shops. They’re mass-produced using CNC milling, but still hand-assembled and inspected. These are the entry points: $399 to $449 new. The most common are the Newport, Newport 2, and Phantom mallet series.
Custom Shop models start as OTR putters that you send in for personalization – stamping, paint fill, grips, shaft bands, and refinished sole. The putter itself costs the same as OTR, but the customization adds $100 to $400, depending on what you choose. I’ve done this twice; the turnaround is about 6 weeks, and the result feels like a one-of-a-kind piece.
Tour and Circle T putters are built for PGA Tour players or limited releases. They’re hand-milled from a single block of carbon or stainless steel, with tighter tolerances, different neck styles, and sometimes carbon fiber inserts. They come with a COA (Certificate of Authenticity) and a price tag that starts around $2,000 for a basic Tour model and easily hits $15,000 for a rare Circle T or game-used pro putter. I’ve seen a Tiger Woods-spec model sell for over $50,000.
The condition also matters. A putter that’s been refinished by the Custom Shop holds value better than one with deep scratches and rust. Original headcover, grip, and shaft band add another $50 to $150 to the resale price.
Scotty Cameron Putter Prices: New Models
Here are the current retail prices as of this year for the most popular new Scotty Cameron models. These are MSRPs from the official site and authorized retailers – you might find them a bit cheaper at big box stores during sales.
| Model | Type | MSRP |
|---|---|---|
| Special Select Newport | Blade | $429 |
| Special Select Newport 2 | Blade | $429 |
| Special Select Fastback | Mid-mallet | $449 |
| Phantom X 5 | Mallet | $449 |
| Phantom X 7.5 | Mallet | $449 |
| Phantom X 9.5 | Mallet | $449 |
| Super Select Golo | Mid-mallet | $429 |
| Special Select Squareback | Mid-mallet | $429 |
These prices include the stock pistol grip (usually a Pistolini Plus) and a headcover. If you want a different grip, you’ll pay extra – more on that later.
Used Scotty Cameron Putters: What to Pay
The used market is where most people buy their first Scotty. Here’s what I’ve seen on eBay, GolfWRX BST, and local classifieds over the past year. I’ll break it down by generation.
Current Generation (Special Select, Phantom X)
Putters from the last 2-3 years that are in good condition (no deep dings, original headcover, original grip) sell for $300 to $380. Mint with plastic still on the grip can fetch $400. If the putter has been used for a full season and shows bag chatter, expect $250 to $300.
Previous Generation (Select, Futura, Studio Select)
Models from 2010 to 2020, like the Select Newport 2 or the Futura X mallet, go for $200 to $300 in good shape. The older Studio Stainless (circa 2003-2005) and Pro Platinum (late 1990s) often sell for $175 to $250. I bought my Studio Stainless for $175; after a refinish, it looked almost new, but the resale value didn’t jump – those aren’t collectible.
Vintage and Collectible Models
Certain older models are valuable. The original Catalina from 1993, the Circa 62 line, and limited runs like the 2003 American Heroes putter can go from $500 to $1,500 depending on condition and completeness.
The key is the box, headcover, and shaft band. I once sold a Circa 62 No. 1 with all original accessories for $800; without them, it would have been $350.
Circle T and Tour Putters on the Used Market
These are a different animal. A basic Circle T (stamped with the Circle T logo) without any pro connection starts around $2,000. If it’s tour-used and has a pro’s stamp or custom neck, it jumps to $3,500 to $8,000.
The rarest I’ve handled was a Kuchar prototype mallet that sold for $12,000. Condition is critical – any refinish by a third party kills the value. Only the Custom Shop or original factory work is acceptable.
The Hidden Costs: Upgrades, Fittings, and Refinishing
Buying the putter is only half the story. Here are the real costs that nobody tells you about.
Grips and Headcovers
A stock grip swap to a different Scotty grip (like the Baby T or Dancing Scotty) costs $25 to $40 if you buy it retail. But if you want a custom grip with your initials engraved from the Custom Shop, that’s $90 to $120. Limited edition headcovers from holiday releases or special events sell for $50 to $150. I’ve seen the 2022 Masters cover go for $300 on eBay.
Weight Kits
If you want to adjust swing weight, Scotty sells weight screw kits for $45 to $80. Tour-level titanium or tungsten weights can cost $200 to $400. I swapped weights on my Phantom X 5 to get it to 360g – cost me $65 and completely changed the feel.
Putter Fitting
A Scotty Cameron putter fitting at an authorized dealer or a dedicated studio runs $50 to $150. Many retailers, like Club Champion or Golf Galaxy, include the fitting fee in the purchase price. I did a full fitting for $120, and it shaved three putts per round. Worth every penny.
Refinishing and Restoration
This is where costs add up fast. A basic refinish from the Custom Shop (sanding, painting, new sight line) starts at $150 for a standard blade and goes to $275 for a mallet. If you want stamping or custom engraving, add $50 to $100. Full restoration with a new shaft, grip, shaft band, and headcover can hit $400. I’ve seen people spend more on a restoration than they did on the putter itself – and they’re happy with it.
Myth vs. Reality: Resale Value and Collectibility
You’ll hear people say, “All old Scotty Camerons are worth a fortune.” That’s mostly wrong.
Myth: Every used Scotty Cameron from 10 years ago is a collectible.
Reality: Most mass-produced models like the Pro Platinum, Studio Stainless, and early 2000s Red X series have actually depreciated in real terms. Adjusted for inflation, a Pro Platinum Newport that cost $285 in 2000 is worth about $200 today. Only specific, limited runs and tour pieces hold or grow in value.
Here are the models that tend to keep their value or increase:
- Circle T and tour-stamped putters (always).
- Limited edition holiday releases (Christmas, Halloween) – especially with original box and cover.
- First-generation models from the 1990s (Catolina, Laguna, Classic).
- Special anniversary models (10th, 15th, 20th).
And the ones that drop:
- Any OTR model after 5 years of regular use.
- Studio Stainless and Pro Platinum (too many were made).
- Putters that have been poorly refinished or have aftermarket stamps.
The Full Build Cost: Custom Scotty Cameron Putter from Scratch
If you want a true one-of-a-kind putter built from a raw head, here’s what you’ll actually spend. I did this last year.
Start with a bare Scotty Cameron head – either a Circle T blank or a standard head that you send for a full custom job. The head itself runs $300 to $800 for a basic OTR, or $1,500+ for a Circle T blank.
Add a custom shaft: $50 to $150 (steel or graphite, length and bend specs).
Custom grip with engraving: $90.
Headcover: $50 to $150, depending on rarity.
Custom paint fill and stamping: $100 to $250.
Fitting session: $100 to $150 (often required to get the lie and loft perfect).
Assembly and final touch-up by the Custom Shop: $75 to $150.
Total for a full build with a standard head: around $800 to $1,200. With a Circle T head: $2,500 to $4,000. That’s what you pay for something that nobody else on the planet owns exactly.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much are Scotty Cameron putter covers?
Standard replacement headcovers from the Custom Shop start at $50. Limited edition covers (e.g., Club Cameron membership covers) run $75 to $150. Rare or pro event covers can be $200 to $500 on the secondary market.
How much is a Scotty Cameron putter fitting?
A full putter fitting at an authorized fitting studio ranges from $50 to $150. Many high-end golf shops will apply the fitting fee toward the purchase of a new putter.
How much to refurbish a Scotty Cameron putter?
Basic refinish (sanding, paint fill, new sight line) starts at $150. Full restoration with new shaft, grip, and headcover runs $300 to $400. If you add custom stamping or a new neck weld, expect $400 to $600.
How much are Scotty Cameron putter weights?
Standard weight screw sets (two screws) cost $45 to $80. Tour-specific titanium or tungsten weights are $200 to $400. You can find used weight kits on eBay for $30 to $50, but be careful of counterfeits.
How much is a Scotty Cameron custom grip?
A standard Pistolini Plus grip is $30. A custom Baby T grip with engraving from the Custom Shop costs around $90 to $100. Limited edition grips (like the Red or Blue Dancing Scotty) go for $50 to $75.
How much are Scotty Cameron Phantom putters specifically?
New Phantom X models have an MSRP of $449 for most heads (5, 7.5, 9.5). The Phantom X 11 and 12 are typically $449 as well. Used Phantoms in good condition sell for $300 to $400, depending on age. The older Futura line (pre-Phantom) goes for $200 to $300.
Why are Scotty Cameron putters so expensive?
Each head is CNC-milled from a solid block of 303 stainless steel or 6061 aluminum (for mallets). The milling process takes about 20 minutes per head. Then each putter is hand-assembled, inspected, and stamped. The brand’s tournament pedigree and resale value also drive the price. You’re paying for precision manufacturing, not marketing hype – though the hype doesn’t hurt.
Knowing exactly how much a Scotty Cameron putter costs – and what you’ll spend on extras – should take the guesswork out of your next purchase. Whether you’re buying your first used Newport or chasing a Circle T grail, you now know the real numbers.